Taking Action: PBS Needs Independents
March 15, 2012
The following is an open letter to PBS. We encourage all independent filmmakers and fans of public media to join us as signatories by commenting below, or emailing us at [email protected], or tweet #PBSNeedsIndies to us on Twitter.
Kartemquin has a long history of supporting public broadcasting, and we feel we must again rise to the challenge in raising our concern, and hopefully awareness and action, over the issues below.
As independent filmmakers, as participants in the evolution of public broadcasting, as viewers and as citizens, we protest PBS’ decision to move the two premier strands of independent documentaries, Independent Lens and POV, from their established home on Tuesday nights to Thursday, a night on which local stations program locally-selected material.
We saw the change in the programming to Thursday night and were concerned about the effect it would have on the ratings. As filmmakers, we are acutely aware of the importance of program placement in a broadcast schedule. With the publishing of the March 12, 2012 article by Dru Sefton in Current magazine, we have now seen documented the dramatic effects of this shift, and that our fears were realized. We cannot wait any longer to signal our concern.
PBS’s programming decision has, effectively, moved these two award-winning series off the main schedule, by leaving it up to stations to program them on their own, on perhaps the most competitive night of the TV week. Both series have carved out a trusted relationship with audiences on Tuesday nights. PBS’ John Wilson has acknowledged that Thursday, a local-programming night, is a “no-fly zone” for PBS programs. Asking stations to drop programming among the most popular with their members is unreasonable.
Public television is not just a popularity contest, or a ratings game. Taxpayers support public broadcasting because democracy needs more than commercial media’s business models can provide. PBS’ programming decision makes a statement about PBS’ commitment to the mission of public broadcasting. We note the definition in the recently-revised and reissued Code of Editorial Integrity for Local Public Media Organizations:
“Our purposes are to support a strong civil society, increase cultural access and knowledge, extend public education, and strengthen community life through electronic media and related community activities.”
These are the stations that PBS serves. These are the stations that are well-served by well-crafted, well-told stories about underrepresented topics, meeting needs of underserved audiences in innovative ways. These are the stations that benefit from community activities related to the strands, such as ITVS’s Community Cinema and LINCS programs. These are the stations that benefit from IL and POV’s constant technological innovation and experiment in engagement. And these are the stations that need to cultivate younger and more diverse audiences, the kind that can be attracted by the innovative, diverse films in these series.
Films such as Where Soldiers Come From, Heather Courtney’s film about Michigan reservists’ journey to Iraq and back; Chris Paine’s Revenge of the Electric Car, about a crucial energy issue; Daisy Bates: First Lady of Little Rock, which revives the memory of the civil rights activist, and was directed by Sharon La Cruise; and Connie Field’s Have You Heard from Johannesburg?, about the history of apartheid, serve important functions at a local and national level, reaching underserved audiences, providing both perspectives and information unavailable in the marketplace, and doing so with expert craft. They serve a critical function in the public broadcasting ecology. They serve the democratic mission of public broadcasting.
We recognize the importance of public broadcasting. We have been able to reach national audiences with significant work, and we have seen meaningful democratic engagement as a result. For instance, when In the Family showed on POV, with a multiplatform campaign, legislation was pending on genetic non-discrimination. The broadcast fostered productive conversations across the nation about the consequences of that discrimination in people’s lives. The showing of Lioness on Independent Lens fostered a broad public discussion of the rights of women veterans who had experienced combat, and was instrumental in the passage of legislation, named for the film, winning these veterans the right to Veterans Administration benefits. The showing of Farmingville on POV fostered deeper, more complex and thoughtful public discussions, both online and in person, on the effect of immigration on local communities. We are deeply concerned that PBS’ poorly-considered decision could jeopardize both the meeting of public broadcasting’s mission and also stifle the innovation that is crucial to the future of public broadcasting.
Signed by:
A.G. Nigrin (Rutgers University)
Aaron G. Woolf (Mosaic Films Inc.)
Alan Adelson (Films for Humanity)
Alan Rogers
Alitza Blough
Allen Haydon
Allen Mondell
Allie LeCaux
Alyssa W.
Amy Bretz
Andrea Mills
Andrea Presson
Andrew Crawford
Andrew Garrison
Andrew Gersh
Andrew Syversen
Anita Holsapple (Gizzy Bear Productions)
Anita J. Malinski
Ann Marie Mitchell
Ann Scott
Anne Burdakin
Anne Hill
Annie Roney (Ro*Co Films International)
Antonio Semeco
Anuradha Rana
Aphrodite Harris
Ardeth L. Weed
Art Citron
Barbara Bowen
Barbara Bullas
Barbara Haynes
Barbara Kinchen
Barbara Kopple (Cabin Creek Films)
Barbara Thorpe
Ben Daviss
Ben Lappin
Benny Cespedes
Bernard Gitlin
Bernardo Ruiz (Quiet Pictures)
Beverly J. Braunlich
Bill Gannon
Bill Moyers & Michael Winship (Public Affairs Television)
Bill Hibbard
Bill Lichtenstein
Bill Kavanagh (Kavanagh Productions)
Bill Siegel
Brenda Logan
Brent and Carol Boykin-Hicks
Brett McNeil
Brian Byrne
Brian Gebbia
Brian Gordon
Brian Wengrofsky
Bryan Wright
Byron Hurt (God Bless the Child Productions)
Cal Skaggs (Lumiere Productions)
Carlos Aguilar
Carl Griesser
Carla Baron
Carol B. Williams
Carole Lucia Satrina
Carole Recore
Carol Barclay
Carol Olwell
Carol Politis
Carol Teicher
Carol Vernallis
Carroll Heins
Carroll Long
Catherine Ellsworth
Catherine Kirkland
Catherine Mullaugh
Catherine Ridley
Catherine Tambini (Camino Bluff)
Celeste T. Kearney
Charlie Goedken
Charles Browne
Charles D. Brown
Charlotte Lagarde (Swell Cinema)
Chiquita Eubanks
Chris Crane
Chuck Van Wey
Cinda Flynn
C.L. Ibes
Constance Mortell
Colleen O’Brien Clopton
Connie Moore
Curtis John Lund
Curtis Miller
Cynthia Mondell
Cyrille Phipps
D. Gagne
Dan Childers (The Papp Project)
Dan Satorius (Satorius Law Firm, PLLC)
Daniel Rainville
Daniel Wolf
Darrell Greco
Daria Price
Darrell Greco
Dave Amundson
Dave Monk (Brave New Pictures)
Dave Mullen
David Cassidy (Cabin Creek Films)
David Demonte
David DeRosa
David Donnenfield (Filmmakers Collaborative SF)
David E. Simpson (Kartemquin Films)
David Graper
David Gregory
David Grubin (David Grubin)
David Handelman
David Hellmann
David L. Wilkins
David Mahoney
David O. Weissman
David Sheppard
David Shever
David Spaltro
David Van Taylor (Lumiere Productions)
Dean Hamer
Deanne Heitkamp
Deborah Dickson (Blackbird Films)
Deborah Linkowski
Dee Ann Royce
DeeDee Halleck
Deena Rosen
Denise Dean
Dennis Sutton
Diana Holtzberg (Films Tranit International, Inc.)
Diane Curlette
Diane Estelle Vicari
Diane Gulbranson
Diane Melloy
Diane Sylvester
Donald Goldmacher
Donna Nelson
Donna Terrence
Donnie L. Betts
Doug Balcom
Doug Blush (Mad Pix, Inc)
E. Ann Villemaire
E. Martens
E. J. Vaughn
Ed Gullo
Elaine Bailey
Elena Mannes
Elizabeth Burleson Mortilla
Elizabeth Karnes Keefe
Elisabeth Haviland James (Thornapple Films)
Elizabeth McGraw-Austin
Elizabeth McMahon
Elizabeth Westrate (Five Spot Films LLC)
Ellen Wagner
Elliott Kalan
Elwood H. LaBrosse
Emmy Scharlatt
Eric V. Tait Jr.
Eugene Rosow
Frank Foster
Frazer Pennebaker (Pennebaker Hegedus Films)
Fred Drumlevitch
Fred Griffith
Freida Mock
Frits J. den Hertog
Gabriel Lataianu
Gail Mallimson (Mallimson Media)
Gail S Preston
Garrett Bader
Garret Savage
Garry Coomans
Gary Cohen (Triple Threat Television)
Gary Ray
Gary Starkweather
Gary Weimberg
Gary W. Longsine
Garry Helms
Gay Leah and Glen Barfield
Gena Hegelman
Gene Messick
Geoffrey Smith (Eyeline Films)
Ginny Durrin (Durrin Productions Inc.)
Glenn Marcus (New Voyage Communications)
Gordon Quinn (Kartemquin Films)
Greg Scott (Sawbuck Productions)
Haley Martin
Hari S. Khalsa
Harry Hanbury (Harry Hanbury Productions)
Heather Courtney
Helen Hood Scheer (Nutshell Productions)
Henry Breitrose (Stanford University)
Henry Norr
Henry R. Post
Herbert V. Missry
Hercules D. Morphopoulos
Holly Butz
Howard Weinberg (Priority Productions, Inc)
Iris Lochner
Izak Smith
J. Huges
Jack McDonald
Jack Spector
Jackie Weissman (Rock Moma Films)
Jack Whalen
Jack Willis
Jacob Bricca
Jacob Kaufman
James Callanan
James Chressanthis
Jan Albert Janet Goldwater (Attie & Goldwater Productions)
James Conlon
James Longley (Daylight Factory LLC)
James Spione (James Spione)
James W. Donaldson
Jane Allgood
Jane Gillooly
Jane Silverman
Jane Snyder
Janet Harrison
Janet Remington
Jan Rofekamp
Jason Fabeck
Jayne Lyn Stahl
Jean Waller
Jef Riffe (Jed Riffe Films)
Jeff Newman
Jeff Toste
Jem Cohen
Jennie Gambach
Jennifer Cool (University of Southern California)
Jennifer Howell
Jeremy Pikser (Writers Guild of America East)
Jerret Engle (CK Studios, Inc)
Jill Jensen
Jim Christiansen
Jim Conlon
Jim McSilver
Jim Phinney
Jim Vavra
Joan Braderman
Joan Konner
Joan McCormick Hollingsworth
Joan Middendorf
Joan Sekler
Jocelyn Boor
Joe Widener
Joe Wilson
Joellen Gilchrist
John Bridge
John Campbell
John Cummings
John de Forest
John Farbstein
John Fecile
John Junkerman
John Kean
John LaDuex
John Latsko
John Littleton
John Michaelson
John Morris
John Patrick Shanley
John Ressler
John Salamack
Jonathan Smoots
Jon Else (University of California, Berkeley)
Jorge Castaneda-Campos
Joseph Clark
Joseph Santarromana
Juan Mandelbaum (Geovision)
Judea Goins-Andrews
Julia Hungerford
Julie Wedge
June Cross (Columbia University)
K. M. Carey
Kambiz Shabankare
Karen Branan
Karen Clark
Karen Coulter
Karen Mezick
Karen Skloss
Karen Twyman
Karen Wilkison
Karl David Reinhardt
Kathi Forssell
Katie Harwood
Kathleen Sonnabend
Kathryn Higuchi
Karhryn Jonas
Kathryn M. Zunich
Kathleen Husler
Kathleen Killinger
Kathryn Hardage
Kathryn Pyle (Honey Alley)
Kathy Cole
Keith Fry
Kelley C. Smith
Kelly Duane de la Vega
Kelly Luchtman
Keri Pickett (Pickett Pictures)
Kevin C. Soles
Kevin Hefferan
Kevin Lambert
Kevin White (Filmmakers Collaborative SF)
Kim Peterson
Kit Burns
Kitty Vangunten
Kristen Brandt
Kristi Barlow
Kristi Jacobson
Kristina Cliff-Evans
Kristine Idarius
Lacey Schwartz (Truth Aid)
Lajwanti Waghray
Lamar Hankins
Lance Kramer (Meridian Hill Pictures)
LaSonya Thompson
Laura Sabransky
Lauren Simon
Leah Fischer
Lee Redfern
Leigh Lehman
Leila Lustig
Lenora Lawrence
Leonard Zamkoff
Leslie Epperson
Leslie Lethridge
Leslie Lutz
Leslie Simmer (Kartemquin Films)
Lily Keber (Mairzy Doats Productions)
Linae Warden
Lincoln Potter
Linda Blackaby (Cinema Projects)
Lisa Zumwait
Liz Cabrera
Liz Garbus
Liz Wassell
Lloyd Cherry
Loira Limbal
Lolly Eggers
Lona Sepessy
Lori Koonce
Lorie Conway
Lowell J. Triplett
Lucinda Nichols
L.W. Dodd
Lynn Devlin
Lynn Geri
Lynn Maynard Gollin
Lynne Belaief
Lynzee Klingman
M. E. Colwell
Macky Alston (Reveal Productions)
Marc Bridgham
Marc Joseph
Marc Smolowitz
Marc Weiss
Margaret Day
Mariel McEwan
Marina Zenovich
Marissa Aroy (Media Factory)
Marjorie Trifon
Mark A. Meggs
Marlo Bendau
Marshall Curry
Martha Miller-Hampton
Martha Spanninger
Martha White
Mary Akashah
Mary Alice
Matt Black
Marcia Hagen
Marilyn Webber
Martin Buechley
Mary Decker
Mary Elizabeth McIlvane
Mary Harris
Mary McCawley
Mary McIlvane
Mary Olive Smith
Matthew Gordon
Matt Klein
Maureen Moffat
Maureen O’Connor
Maurice P. Held
Maxine Haytin
Megan Mylan
Michael Fox (New Channel Media)
Michael Phillips
Michael Thornton
Michael V. Kniat
Mick Benderoth
Mike Bradley
Mike Dysinger
Mike Farrell
Mike Rega
Miki Magyar
Milo Vannucci
Miriam MacGillis
Molly Malone
Monica Riley
Monte Montgomery
Nadia Michelle Robertson (1931 Productions)
Nancy Kelly
Nancy Weant
Natalie Peart (Women Make Movies)
Neal Madnick
Neal McNamara
Neil O’Sullivan
Neil Peterson
Nell F. Cox
Nettie Toeller
Nicole Docta (371 Productions)
Nicole Franklin (Epiphany Inc)
Nicole Perrot
Noreen Bloch
Pamela Yates (Skylight Pictures)
Patricia Flynn
Pat Kelly
Patty Clucas
Patricia Lazz
Patricia Murphy
Patricia Quinlan
Patrick Yacco
Patsy Washburn
Paul Andrew Lawrence
Paul Bonesteel (Bonesteel Films)
Paul E. Sjordal
Paul Wagner
Peter Forges
Peter Kuttner
Peter Rosen
Phil Corn
Phil Rippke
Philip Palombo
Philip V. Hull
Pratibha Parmar (Kali Films)
Quentin B. Deming
Ralph Niebuhr
R. Brooke Lewis
Regan Brashear
Reiner Peery
Renee Gayle Brutvan (New Urbanism)
Rich Burlingham (TMF Entertainment)
Richard Fidler
Richard Garella
Richard Jackman
Richard Notter
Rick Boyd
Rick Goldsmith
Rick Minnich
Riley Naff
Rita Rausch
Ritchie Albert
Rob Baxter
Rob and Sherry De Mandel
Robert W. Belew
Robert Barnhart
Robert Cruickshank
Robert Davies
Robert and Virginia Ghirardelli
Robert Watts
Roberta Beach
Roger Ludke
Roger Pelizzari
Roger P. Hancock
Ron Shackelford
Rosalie Bishop
Rosalie MacCready
Rosemary Rotondi
Rose Marie Kirwin
Rose Rosenblatt (Incite Pictures)
Rose Stevens
Ruth Leon
Ruth M. Black
Ryan Early
Ryan Gleeson
Ryan Jacobi
Ryan Krivoshey (The Cinema Guild)
Russell Long (Sacred Planet Films)
Russell Martin (Say Yes Quickly Productions)
Ruth Leitman (Ruthless Films)
S. Gluck
S. Newell
Sally Boyson
Sally Rubin (Chapman University)
Samuel Gerace
Sara Booth
Sarah M.
Sarah Woodside Gallagher
Schuyler Gould
Sean Welch
Shanita Lawrence
Sharon La Cruise (Sakkara Films)
Sharon R. Weinblatt
Sheena Joyce (9.14 Pictures)
Sheldan Collins
Shelley Stallings
Sian Evans
Sid Kivanoski
Sky Sitney
Stacia Simmons
Stanley Nelson (Firelight Media)
Stella Townsend
Stephanie Cunningham
Stephanie Mortenson
Stephanie Wang-Breal
Stephen Margulis
Stephen Most
Stephen Nielsen
Steve Golden
Steve Mendelsohn (Arts Engine)
Steven Lippman
Steven Walsh
Stuart Simon
Su Friedrich
Sue Duffy
Susan Hodnot
Susan Kim
Susan Mumpower-Spriggs
Susan Suntree
Susan Squires
Susie Czarnecki
Susi Walsh
Suzanne Farwell
Suzy Valentine
Swati Srivastava
Sylvia Diss
T. Bass
Tammie McCrary
Tammy Cromer-Campbell (Tammy Cromer-Campbell)
Thomas Washburn
Tim Horsburgh (Kartemquin Films)
Tod Lending
Tom Ackerson
Tom Boschert
Tom Caine
Tom Fontana
Tom Knoff
Tom Harman
Tom McKenna
Tom Wilson
Tracie Holder (The Papp Project)
Tracy S. Troth
Tristan Creeley
Trudy Brown
Tucker Robbins
Urania Messing
V. Hernandez
Valerie C. Rhodes (Carbo Films)
Valerie Solomon
Van Waggoner
VennieEline White
Veronica L. Feinstein
Vickie Marton
Victoria Light
Video Production San Diego
Virginia Carlson
Virginia Carlisle
Virginia Kassel
Virginia Rigney
Vivian Price
Walter Fox
Wayne Johnson
Whitney Dow
Will Spires
William D. Livergood
William Lex
William Nichols
William Rasmussen
William Segen
William Solomon
William Wade
Wyndham Boulter
Xan Parker
Yon Wacker