Funding scheme leads to
exit
Florida station head quits over auction venture
Originally published in Current,
Oct. 8, 1990
By Stephen Singer
A state investigation of a for-profit corporation that raised
money for WJCT-TV/FM in Jacksonville, Fla., and payment of $166,000
in commissions to the stations' president have forced his resignation.
In addition, the Jacksonville City Council and county school district
have temporarily withheld more than $300,000 in funding while the investigation
is pending.
Fred J. Rebman ended his 28-year tenure at WJCT in late August.
His resignation came shortly after local newspapers reported that Rebman
received 5 percent in commissions from a furniture auction that raised
money for the station and five other outlets in Florida and Georgia.
Rebman was president of Florida Television Charity Inc., the for-profit
company that ran the auction.
Rebman, 56, received commissions totaling $166,000 in 18 months,
according to station spokesman Vic DiGenti. Rebman, who denies receiving
$166,000 in commissions, also had a salary at WJCT of $130,000.
``I have serious questions why he set up the corporation,'' said
city Councilman Harry Reagan, an ex-commercial broadcaster who has been
a sharp critic of Rebman.
Reagan said he has introduced council resolutions to ``take steps
to restore [WJCT's] public credibility,'' calling for full disclosure
of fundraising campaigns. ``No one in the public or city government
knew what was going on. There was no disclosure of a corporation like
that, or a disclosure that 5 percent was going to the general manager,''
he said.
Robert Shircliff, treasurer of the station's board of directors
and a member of the board of Florida Television Charity, said he could
not say ``whether or not every member of the city council'' was aware
of the for-profit firm.
The board of directors of the for-profit corporation comprised
members of the executive committee of WJCT's board of directors. In
addition to Shircliff, members were Wilford Lyon Jr., Ira Koger, William
Birchfield and E. Bruce Bower.
``People here are not as sophisticated as people in New York
or Chicago,'' Rebman said. In a press conference called to announce
that the for-profit operation was established, ``we tried really hard
explaining the Nixon and Reagan years when arts groups had to get off
the federal dole. We attempted to educate the public. This is nothing
new,'' he said.
According to an audit of WJCT financial records, which is conducted
at the end of each fiscal year, ``everything is in order, everything
is accounted for,'' DiGenti said.
Rebman said his commissions — 2.5 percent of auction revenue
paid by the for-profit subsidiary and 2.5 percent from the furniture
company that provided the auction goods — was far less than $166,000.
``It was closer to $82,000 in 15 months. Annualizing that, it would
be about $60,000 or $66,000. For a $4 million-to-$5 million gross business,
that's really tiny.''
Rebman said he established the for-profit venture to comply with
Internal Revenue Service regulations requiring separation from the non-profit
stations. ``You must operate as if the two are absolutely, totally apart,''
he said.
The ex-station chief said Assistant State Attorney E. McRae Mathis
has ``nothing to investigate.'' He ``felt there was enough smoke to
take a look. Auctions have been done by public TV stations around the
country,'' he added.
Mathis said he will ``probably not have anything meaningful to
say'' until he is further into the probe. ``I'm not prepared to discuss
what the scope of the investigation is,'' he said.
``We're getting information from a number of parties,'' he said
without elaborating. ``Information came to our office's attention through
the same information provided to the media. The same people they were
talking to contacted us.''
Rebman said Pioneer Antiques, which worked with WJCT in purchasing
furniture that would be auctioned, ``went to the press.'' Furniture
company owner Alley Watts is suing WJCT for $40,000 he claims the station
owes him, DiGenti said. WJCT is counter-suing the firm for $36,000 for
failing to provide furniture the station insists should have been returned,
he added.
Alley Watts, head of the antiques firm, could not be reached
for comment.
The Jacksonville City Council has deferred payment of $98,000
to the station until city officials get results from the state attorney's
investigation, Reagan said. WJCT airs taped broadcasts of council meetings
at 10 p.m., though city officials preferred live broadcasts at 7:30
p.m., he said.
WJCT officials said live coverage would cost underwriting and
subscriber funding, Reagan added. ``The city council was unhappy about
it, but there was not much we could do about it,'' he said.
``This, coming on top of a plea [for money] last year was very disturbing
to some council members,'' Reagan said. WJCT officials told council
members of the meeting broadcasts after the city budget was approved,
he said. ``There was some feeling that that was no coincidence. That
kind of manipulation upset some council members,'' he said.
Duval County Public Schools also has delayed final action on
a contract that would pay WJCT $225,000 — and a planned 7 percent
increase, to $240,000 — for instructional TV services ``until
more questions are answered,'' ITV Supervisor Michael Ard said.
As with the city, WJCT changed last year from live broadcasts
of school board meetings to delayed taped airings, Ard said. ``Some
of the board members and city council people took issue with it,'' he
said.
``Every year the WJCT contract has been something the board has questioned
or had concerns about,'' Ard said. ``While it's unfortunate this incident
brought things to a head, it served as a catalyst for the board to see
what other alternatives to WJCT exist,'' Ard added.
School board members are ``aware of technology offerings, and questioned
if this is the most efficient way to spend our money. It's a lot of
money,'' Ard said.
School officials will make a decision soon about whether to continue
services with WJCT, establish an instructional television fixed service,
share equipment with community colleges equipment or find another arrangement,
Ard said.
The for-profit firm raised more than $800,000 in the 18 months
it has been in operation, DiGenti said. Each of the TV stations that
participated in the auctions — which include WJCT, WLRN in Miami,
WMFE in Orlando, Fla., WEMU in Tampa, Fla., WFSU in Tallahassee, Fla.,
and WPBA in Atlanta — received 25 percent of gross profits, he
said.
That amounted to $260,000 in two or three auctions. Money from
Florida Public TV Charities also was used for personnel, overhead and
purchase of products, DiGenti said.
The for-profit corporation still operates, but officials are
"contemplating changing it to a nonprofit, if they have not already
done it,'' he added.